Warning: Table './davidk9_korten/watchdog' is marked as crashed and should be repaired query: INSERT INTO watchdog (uid, type, message, variables, severity, link, location, referer, hostname, timestamp) VALUES (0, 'php', '%message in %file on line %line.', 'a:4:{s:6:\"%error\";s:12:\"user warning\";s:8:\"%message\";s:225:\"Table './davidk9_korten/cache_filter' is marked as crashed and should be repaired\nquery: SELECT data, created, headers, expire, serialized FROM cache_filter WHERE cid = '2:b426a49d72b26fbf2603331498e5bcaf'\";s:5:\"%file\";s:44:\"/home/davidk9/public_html/includes/cache.inc\";s:5:\"%line\";i:27;}', 3, '', 'http://livingeconomiesforum.org/1991/11KORTEN', '', '54.234.59.94', 1411250454) in /home/davidk9/public_html/includes/database.mysqli.inc on line 134

Warning: Table './davidk9_korten/watchdog' is marked as crashed and should be repaired query: INSERT INTO watchdog (uid, type, message, variables, severity, link, location, referer, hostname, timestamp) VALUES (0, 'php', '%message in %file on line %line.', 'a:4:{s:6:\"%error\";s:12:\"user warning\";s:8:\"%message\";s:6342:\"Table './davidk9_korten/cache_filter' is marked as crashed and should be repaired\nquery: UPDATE cache_filter SET data = '<P>PCDForum Column #11 Release Date April 12, 1991</p>\\n<P> by David C. Korten</p>\\n\\n<P>A few years ago a major multi-agency study of foreign aid\\nobserved that from two-thirds to three-fourths of development projects funded by official foreign donors are judged\\nby the donor to be satisfactory at the time project implementation is completed and the donor withdraws. Only\\nrarely do donors look a in /home/davidk9/public_html/includes/database.mysqli.inc on line 134

Warning: Table './davidk9_korten/watchdog' is marked as crashed and should be repaired query: INSERT INTO watchdog (uid, type, message, variables, severity, link, location, referer, hostname, timestamp) VALUES (0, 'php', '%message in %file on line %line.', 'a:4:{s:6:\"%error\";s:12:\"user warning\";s:8:\"%message\";s:225:\"Table './davidk9_korten/cache_filter' is marked as crashed and should be repaired\nquery: SELECT data, created, headers, expire, serialized FROM cache_filter WHERE cid = '2:b58ca6f079e76db811a18072e9c4773e'\";s:5:\"%file\";s:44:\"/home/davidk9/public_html/includes/cache.inc\";s:5:\"%line\";i:27;}', 3, '', 'http://livingeconomiesforum.org/1991/11KORTEN', '', '54.234.59.94', 1411250454) in /home/davidk9/public_html/includes/database.mysqli.inc on line 134

Warning: Table './davidk9_korten/watchdog' is marked as crashed and should be repaired query: INSERT INTO watchdog (uid, type, message, variables, severity, link, location, referer, hostname, timestamp) VALUES (0, 'php', '%message in %file on line %line.', 'a:4:{s:6:\"%error\";s:12:\"user warning\";s:8:\"%message\";s:1482:\"Table './davidk9_korten/cache_filter' is marked as crashed and should be repaired\nquery: UPDATE cache_filter SET data = '<ul>\\n <li><a href=\\"http://livingeconomiesforum.org/newsletter-signup\\">Get our e-newsletter</a></li>\\n <li>Follow us via …\\n <ul class=\\"clearfix\\">\\n <li id=\\"header-rss-badge\\"><a href=\\"http://feeds.feedburner.com/living-economies-forum\\"><img alt=\ in /home/davidk9/public_html/includes/database.mysqli.inc on line 134

Warning: Table './davidk9_korten/watchdog' is marked as crashed and should be repaired query: INSERT INTO watchdog (uid, type, message, variables, severity, link, location, referer, hostname, timestamp) VALUES (0, 'php', '%message in %file on line %line.', 'a:4:{s:6:\"%error\";s:12:\"user warning\";s:8:\"%message\";s:225:\"Table './davidk9_korten/cache_filter' is marked as crashed and should be repaired\nquery: SELECT data, created, headers, expire, serialized FROM cache_filter WHERE cid = '2:d91030d7ccb07a223b16a827e96eba38'\";s:5:\"%file\";s:44:\"/home/davidk9/public_html/includes/cache.inc\";s:5:\"%line\";i:27;}', 3, '', 'http://livingeconomiesforum.org/1991/11KORTEN', '', '54.234.59.94', 1411250454) in /home/davidk9/public_html/includes/database.mysqli.inc on line 134

Warning: Table './davidk9_korten/watchdog' is marked as crashed and should be repaired query: INSERT INTO watchdog (uid, type, message, variables, severity, link, location, referer, hostname, timestamp) VALUES (0, 'php', '%message in %file on line %line.', 'a:4:{s:6:\"%error\";s:12:\"user warning\";s:8:\"%message\";s:4109:\"Table './davidk9_korten/cache_filter' is marked as crashed and should be repaired\nquery: UPDATE cache_filter SET data = '<ul class=\\"clearfix\\" id=\\"footer-links\\">\\n <li><a href=\\"/davids-story\\">David Korten</a>\\n <ul>\\n <li><a href=\\"http://www.yesmagazine.org/blogs/david-korten\\">Blog</a></li>\\n <li><a href=\\"/public-calendar\\"> in /home/davidk9/public_html/includes/database.mysqli.inc on line 134
THE SUSTAINABLE PROJECT: A CONTRADICTION | Living Economies Forum

THE SUSTAINABLE PROJECT: A CONTRADICTION

  • user warning: Table './davidk9_korten/cache_filter' is marked as crashed and should be repaired query: SELECT data, created, headers, expire, serialized FROM cache_filter WHERE cid = '2:b426a49d72b26fbf2603331498e5bcaf' in /home/davidk9/public_html/includes/cache.inc on line 27.
  • user warning: Table './davidk9_korten/cache_filter' is marked as crashed and should be repaired query: UPDATE cache_filter SET data = '<P>PCDForum Column #11 Release Date April 12, 1991</p>\n<P> by David C. Korten</p>\n\n<P>A few years ago a major multi-agency study of foreign aid\nobserved that from two-thirds to three-fourths of development projects funded by official foreign donors are judged\nby the donor to be satisfactory at the time project implementation is completed and the donor withdraws. Only\nrarely do donors look at whether project benefits are in\nfact sustained beyond their withdrawal. One of the rare\nexceptions is a special study of 25 World Bank agricultural projects that were rated successful by the Bank at\ntime of project completion and then re-evaluated several\nyears later. The result: thirteen of the twenty-five successful projects were reclassified as failures because they did\nnot produce a continuing stream of benefits sufficient to\njustify the investment.</p>\n\n<P> Recognition that all too few development projects\nproduce lasting results has created considerable interest in\nthe \"sustainable\" project. The continued focus on the\nproject, however, ignores the extent to which the failure is\ninherent in the project mechanism. Two exercises from a\nhealth planning workshop I helped facilitate in Nigeria in\nlate 1970 illustrate the problem.</p>\n\n<P> Early in the program a team of WHO consultants\npresented a national primary health plan they had developed for the Nigerian government. Using ratios of required facilities and staff per thousand population they\ndetermined the numbers of new primary health centers and\nauxiliary health posts, and the exact numbers of new\nhealth professionals required--without reference to\nexisting facilities or personnel. These new requirements\nwere then translated into a very large budget.</p>\n\n<P> In a later session, workshop participants were divided\ninto three groups. Each group received a case scenario of\nan actual Nigerian community and was asked to develop\na plan for addressing the community\'s priority health\nneeds. The resulting plans called for such actions as\norganizing volunteer labor to drain a mosquito infested\nswamp, engaging religious leaders in support of health\neducation efforts, recruiting a local doctor to train indigenous practitioners, and improving a local mission hospital.\nNo one recommended the construction of a new health\nfacility or the hiring of any new medical staff.</p>\n\n<P>&nbsp;The WHO plan was well suited to presentation as a\ndonor funded project. It called for a standard set of new\nresources, easy to detail in budgetary line items and\naccount for in project reports. At the same time it was\nenormously wasteful, had no relationship to reality, and\nmade no attempt to improve the use of existing resources.\nIn contrast, the plans produced by the workshop participants identified processes aimed at mobilizing existing\nresources to produce sustainable improvements in health.\nThis approach made their plans poorly suited to project\npackaging for donor financing.</p>\n\n<P> By definition a project is a self-contained activity\nwith a clear beginning, end, outcome, and resource\nrequirements. It is by nature insular and inward looking,\nwhereas sustainability depends on an outward orientation\nfocused on enhancing the ability of beneficiaries to control\nand manage their own locally available resources to\nproduce a sustained flow of benefits for themselves. Such\nan outward orientation represents a violation of accepted\nproject management practice, which assumes the project\nmanager has control of all relevant resources and is\naccountable to the donor for their use. People or resources\nbeyond his control are not supposed to be his concern.</p>\n\n<P> To have the required control, the essential project\nresources must come from some external agency, with full\nauthority assigned to the project management unit. This\nposes a fundamental dilemma. The greater the share of\ntotal resources provided by the project and the greater the\nproject\'s control over those resources, the less likely the\nproject will be to contribute to development of new\ncapacities to mobilize and use local resources on a sustained basis. As the emphasis on external resources and\naccountability is inherent in the project mechanism, it is\nnot surprising that sustainable outcomes are rare.</p>\n\n<P> The transfer of large blocks of money in project\npackages--the business of the large official donors--seldom provides more than temporary benefits to contractors, suppliers, politicians, and bureaucrats. Engaging in\nsustained people-to-people cooperation aimed at increasing local control, access to, and productive use of existing\nresources is more naturally suited to voluntary development agencies--so long as they avoid becoming trapped\ninto replicating the incapacities of official donors.</p>\n\n<P>_______________</p>\n\n<P>David C. Korten is founder and president of the People-Centered Development Forum. This column was prepared\nand distributed by the People-Centered Development Forum.</p>\n\n<P><!--webbot bot=\"Navigation\" S-Type=\"arrows\" S-Orientation=\"horizontal\"\nS-Rendering=\"graphics\" B-Include-Home=\"TRUE\" B-Include-Up=\"TRUE\" U-Page S-Target startspan\n--><nobr>[&nbsp;<a href=\"10LEGER\" target=\"\">Back</a>&nbsp;]</nobr> <nobr>[&nbsp;<a href=\"../\" target=\"\">Home</a>&nbsp;]</nobr> <nobr>[&nbsp;<a href=\"../1991\" target=\"\">Parent&nbsp;Page</a>&nbsp;]</nobr> <nobr>[&nbsp;<a href=\"12KORTEN\" target=\"\">Next</a>&nbsp;]</nobr><!--webbot bot=\"Navigation\" endspan i-checksum=\"38103\"\n-->\n</p>\n', created = 1411250454, expire = 1411336854, headers = '', serialized = 0 WHERE cid = '2:b426a49d72b26fbf2603331498e5bcaf' in /home/davidk9/public_html/includes/cache.inc on line 112.
  • user warning: Table './davidk9_korten/cache_filter' is marked as crashed and should be repaired query: SELECT data, created, headers, expire, serialized FROM cache_filter WHERE cid = '2:b58ca6f079e76db811a18072e9c4773e' in /home/davidk9/public_html/includes/cache.inc on line 27.
  • user warning: Table './davidk9_korten/cache_filter' is marked as crashed and should be repaired query: UPDATE cache_filter SET data = '<ul>\n <li><a href=\"http://livingeconomiesforum.org/newsletter-signup\">Get our e-newsletter</a></li>\n <li>Follow us via …\n <ul class=\"clearfix\">\n <li id=\"header-rss-badge\"><a href=\"http://feeds.feedburner.com/living-economies-forum\"><img alt=\"RSS\" src=\"/sites/files/images/rss-badge.gif\" width=\"36\" height=\"36\" /></a></li>\n <li id=\"header-twitter-badge\"><a href=\"http://twitter.com/dkorten\"><img alt=\"Twitter\" src=\"/sites/files/images/twitter-badge.gif\" width=\"37\" height=\"36\" /></a></li>\n <li id=\"header-facebook-badge\"><a href=\"http://www.facebook.com/davidkorten\"><img alt=\"Facebook\" src=\"/sites/files/images/facebook-badge.gif\" width=\"36\" height=\"36\" /></a></li>\n </ul>\n </li>\n <li><a href=\"/how-to-get-involved\">How to get involved</a></li>\n</ul>\n', created = 1411250454, expire = 1411336854, headers = '', serialized = 0 WHERE cid = '2:b58ca6f079e76db811a18072e9c4773e' in /home/davidk9/public_html/includes/cache.inc on line 112.
  • user warning: Table './davidk9_korten/cache_filter' is marked as crashed and should be repaired query: SELECT data, created, headers, expire, serialized FROM cache_filter WHERE cid = '2:d91030d7ccb07a223b16a827e96eba38' in /home/davidk9/public_html/includes/cache.inc on line 27.
  • user warning: Table './davidk9_korten/cache_filter' is marked as crashed and should be repaired query: UPDATE cache_filter SET data = '<ul class=\"clearfix\" id=\"footer-links\">\n <li><a href=\"/davids-story\">David Korten</a>\n <ul>\n <li><a href=\"http://www.yesmagazine.org/blogs/david-korten\">Blog</a></li>\n <li><a href=\"/public-calendar\">Speaking Schedule</a></li>\n <li><a href=\"/davids-story\">David\'s Story</a></li>\n <li><a href=\"/the-forums-defining-books\">Books</a></li>\n <li><a href=\"/Articles\">Articles</a></li>\n <li><a href=\"/presentations\">Presentations</a></li>\n <li><a href=\"/reflections-reports\">Reflections/Reports</a></li>\n </ul>\n </li>\n <li><a href=\"/about-the-forum\">About Us</a>\n <ul>\n <li><a href=\"/our-partners\">Our Partners</a></li>\n <li><a href=\"/governing-board\"> Our Board </a></li>\n <li><a href=\"/living-economies-history\">Learning from Life</a></li>\n <li><a href=\"/story-revolution\">The Story Revolution</a></li>\n <li><a href=\"http://livingeconomiesforum.org/how-to-get-involved\">How to Get Involved</a></li>\n <li><a href=\"/newsletter-signup\">Get Our Email Newsletter</a></li>\n <li><a href=\"/contact\">Contact</a></li>\n </ul>\n </li>\n <li><a href=\"/the-new-economy\">New Economy 2.0</a>\n <ul>\n <li><a href=\"/a-healthy-economy\">A Healthy Economy</a></li>\n <li><a href=\"/life-as-teacher\">Life as Teacher</a></li>\n <li><a href=\"http://livingeconomiesforum.org/emergence-and-displacement\">Emergence Strategy</a></li>\n <li><a href=\"/healthy-markets\">Healthy Markets</a>\n <ul>\n <li><a href=\"/ten-rules-for-socially-efficient-markets\">Market Rules</a></li>\n <li><a href=\"/seven-deadly-sins\">Deadly Sins</a></li>\n </ul>\n </li>\n <li><a href=\"/money-rules\">Money as a Power System</a></li>\n <li><a href=\"/seven-system-action-points-to-advance-the-new-economy\">System Intervention Points</a></li>\n <li><a href=\"/what%27s-new\">Contrasting Visions</a></li>\n <li><a href=\"/new-economy-resources\">Resources</a></li>\n </ul>\n </li>\n <li><a href=\"/great-turning\">The Great Turning</a>\n <ul>\n <li><a href=\"/the-great-turning-in-bullet-points\">Bullet Point Overview</a></li>\n <li><a href=\"/story-power\">Story Power</a>\n <ul>\n <li><a href=\"/cultural-trance\">Cultural Trance</a></li>\n <li><a href=\"/test-yourself\">Self-Test for Trance</a></li>\n </ul>\n </li>\n <li><a href=\"/empire\">Empire</a></li>\n <li><a href=\"/earth-community\">Earth Community</a></li>\n <li><a href=\"/great-turning-resources\">Resources for Study</a></li>\n </ul>\n </li>\n</ul>\n', created = 1411250454, expire = 1411336854, headers = '', serialized = 0 WHERE cid = '2:d91030d7ccb07a223b16a827e96eba38' in /home/davidk9/public_html/includes/cache.inc on line 112.

PCDForum Column #11 Release Date April 12, 1991

by David C. Korten

A few years ago a major multi-agency study of foreign aid observed that from two-thirds to three-fourths of development projects funded by official foreign donors are judged by the donor to be satisfactory at the time project implementation is completed and the donor withdraws. Only rarely do donors look at whether project benefits are in fact sustained beyond their withdrawal. One of the rare exceptions is a special study of 25 World Bank agricultural projects that were rated successful by the Bank at time of project completion and then re-evaluated several years later. The result: thirteen of the twenty-five successful projects were reclassified as failures because they did not produce a continuing stream of benefits sufficient to justify the investment.

Recognition that all too few development projects produce lasting results has created considerable interest in the "sustainable" project. The continued focus on the project, however, ignores the extent to which the failure is inherent in the project mechanism. Two exercises from a health planning workshop I helped facilitate in Nigeria in late 1970 illustrate the problem.

Early in the program a team of WHO consultants presented a national primary health plan they had developed for the Nigerian government. Using ratios of required facilities and staff per thousand population they determined the numbers of new primary health centers and auxiliary health posts, and the exact numbers of new health professionals required--without reference to existing facilities or personnel. These new requirements were then translated into a very large budget.

In a later session, workshop participants were divided into three groups. Each group received a case scenario of an actual Nigerian community and was asked to develop a plan for addressing the community's priority health needs. The resulting plans called for such actions as organizing volunteer labor to drain a mosquito infested swamp, engaging religious leaders in support of health education efforts, recruiting a local doctor to train indigenous practitioners, and improving a local mission hospital. No one recommended the construction of a new health facility or the hiring of any new medical staff.

 The WHO plan was well suited to presentation as a donor funded project. It called for a standard set of new resources, easy to detail in budgetary line items and account for in project reports. At the same time it was enormously wasteful, had no relationship to reality, and made no attempt to improve the use of existing resources. In contrast, the plans produced by the workshop participants identified processes aimed at mobilizing existing resources to produce sustainable improvements in health. This approach made their plans poorly suited to project packaging for donor financing.

By definition a project is a self-contained activity with a clear beginning, end, outcome, and resource requirements. It is by nature insular and inward looking, whereas sustainability depends on an outward orientation focused on enhancing the ability of beneficiaries to control and manage their own locally available resources to produce a sustained flow of benefits for themselves. Such an outward orientation represents a violation of accepted project management practice, which assumes the project manager has control of all relevant resources and is accountable to the donor for their use. People or resources beyond his control are not supposed to be his concern.

To have the required control, the essential project resources must come from some external agency, with full authority assigned to the project management unit. This poses a fundamental dilemma. The greater the share of total resources provided by the project and the greater the project's control over those resources, the less likely the project will be to contribute to development of new capacities to mobilize and use local resources on a sustained basis. As the emphasis on external resources and accountability is inherent in the project mechanism, it is not surprising that sustainable outcomes are rare.

The transfer of large blocks of money in project packages--the business of the large official donors--seldom provides more than temporary benefits to contractors, suppliers, politicians, and bureaucrats. Engaging in sustained people-to-people cooperation aimed at increasing local control, access to, and productive use of existing resources is more naturally suited to voluntary development agencies--so long as they avoid becoming trapped into replicating the incapacities of official donors.

_______________

David C. Korten is founder and president of the People-Centered Development Forum. This column was prepared and distributed by the People-Centered Development Forum.

Back ] Home ] Parent Page ] Next ]